Napa Valley Winery Reviews
NAPA WINERIES

BERINGER

BEAULIEU VINEYARD
CAIN VINEYARD & WINERY
CAKEBREAD
CAYMUS
CHATEAU MONTELENA
CHIMNEY ROCK
CLOS PEGASE
COSENTINO
CUVAISON
DOMAIN CARNEROS
DOMAIN CHANDON
FORMAN VINEYARDS
FRANCISCAN
FREEMARK ABBEY
FROG'S LEAP
GRGICH HILLS CELLARS
GROTH
HEITZ
THE HESS COLLECTION
MERRYVALE
ROBERT MONDAVI
MUMM NAPA VALLEY
NAPA WINE COMPANY
NIEBAUM-COPPOLA ESTATE WINERY
OPUS ONE
PEJU PROVINCE
JOSPEH PHELPS VINEYARDS
PINE RIDGE
PLUMPJACK
ROMBAUER
SHAFER VINEYARDS
SILVERADO
SILVEROAK CELLARS
SPOTTSWOODE WINERY
STAG'S LEAP WINE CELLARS
STERLING VINEYARDS
VAN DER HEYDEN
VIADER VINEYARDS
WHITEHALL LANE

 

WINERY REVIEW KEY

All H. Montanile™ reviews are on a scale of "1" to "12" bottles. 
The highest rating is "12" =  "BUY A CASE"
A rating of  9 and above =  Excellent 
8 to 9 =  Very Good
6 to 8 =  Good to Average
5 to 6 =  Average
5 and below =  Poor to Fair

The Wine is rated on its appearance, bouquet and taste. 

The Ambiance (experience) reflects the physical environment of the tasting room and the knowledge and courtesy of the staff. 
The Winery Review is a reflection of its individual characteristics and the physical aesthetic qualities of the winery and it's grounds. 

The ratings reflect wines available only for tasting, not those wines available for sale at the winery or your local retailer.  The wines available for tasting obviously change with each vintage.

The art of wine tasting is a unique experience and ultimately subjective. We at H. Montanile hope to guide you through a wonderful and delicious experience in Napa and Sonoma.  

 

- Picnicking is permitted at these wineries.

  - Grape Note.

BEAULIEU VINEYARD 1960 St. Helena Highway (Hwy 29), Rutherford, 707.967.5230 HOURS: Tasting: 10:00-5:00 Tours: 11:00-4:00 daily Tasting Fee: Georges Latour Reserve room only ($18.00)

BEAULIEU is pronounced "bale" "u". Skip the regular tasting room and head straight for the reserve room.  The wines are spectacular.


Click for larger image

10 WINE: The Latour Reserve room offers an array of Vintages. These classic vintages are also for sale. All of these fine wines, in keeping with the Georges Latour tradition, are the standard by which all other cabs are measured.
10

AMBIANCE:

The tasting room is simple and elegant. The staff walks you through your tasting, offering insights into each one of these fabulous wines.
8

WINERY:

Several small rustic and brick buildings adorn these quaint grounds. Take the tour and enjoy.

BERINGER 2000 Main Street (Hwy 29), St. Helena 707.963.4813 HOURS: Tasting: 10:00-6:00 Tasting Fee: for reserve tasting Tours: 10:00-5:00 daily


Click for larger image

9 WINE: Beringer produces a full array of wines. All are consistently good. The reserve Cabernet is a knockout. Reserves are poured for a fee in the upstairs of the Rhine house.
10

AMBIANCE:

Perfectly suited for a delightful afternoon of wine tasting. The staff is both knowledgeable and friendly.
12

WINERY:

Flowered gardens decorate one of the more historic wineries of the valley. The Rhine house, which was constructed in the latter half of the 19th century, epitomizes the elegance of this winery. Tours through the original aging cellars should not be missed. Sniff, sip, sit and enjoy!
CAIN VINEYARD & WINERY 3800 Langtry Road St., Helena 707.963.1616 HOURS: Tastings & Tours: given Thursday - Saturday and by appointment only. Tasting fee: None


Click for larger image

9.5 WINE: The Cain Musque (white) is partially malolactic fermented with a floral bouquet. The 1997 Cain Cuvee is loaded with tannins and is billed as a Bistro wine. The 1996 Cain Concept, currently the only estate bottled wine, is a delicious wine, which was a little tight still with tannins yet, not overwhelming. The 1996 Cain Five is an excellent Bordeaux styled wine with firm tannins with years to age, the true star of the Cain family.
10

AMBIANCE:

You are greeted by a warm and friendly staff that will take you on an informative tour of Cain's fabulous winery with a tasting that follows in a delightful room around a large wooden table.

12

WINERY:

A fabulous drive along Spring Mountain high on top of a ridge sits Cain. The magnificent views are absolutely breathtaking and worth the journey, a twenty five-minute ride from the town of St. Helena and an absolute must. Take your camera and enjoy.
CAKEBREAD  8300 St. Helena Way (Hwy 29), Rutherford 707.963.5221 HOURS: Tasting: 10:00-4:30 Tasting Fee: $3.00 for non-vintners/$5.00 for vintners/etched glass included with both Tours: by appointment.


Click for larger image

9.5 WINE: Consistently good wines are poured from this vineyard. The fragrant sauvignon Blanc is a winner. The cabernet is one of the finest and an excellent edition to your cellar.
10

AMBIANCE:

Intimate tasting rooms with a sophisticated and friendly staff.

8

WINERY:

Beautiful flowers welcome you to this charming new winery, opened in 1996. Parking is limited so arrive early.
CAYMUS 8700 Conn Creek Road, Rutherford 707.967.HOURS: Tasting: 10:00-3:00 on the hour by appointment - no fee Tours: none

 

CAYMUS' has been the recipient of the unparalleled award winning reputation by WINE SPECTATOR.


Click for larger image

11 WINE: Tasting includes CAYMUS' white selection including the delicious Conundrum, which is only sold at the vineyard. Although, the Special Select Cabernet will no longer be poured, Caymus' cabernets are stellar. Buy when released, as Caymus will sell it's entire stock and cellars nothing. First come, first served.
10

AMBIANCE:

Simple yet elegant.  Tastings are offered in small groups (by appointment only), in a lovely room seated around a large wooden table.  The sommelier educates you about Caymus and the wines during the relaxing and delightful tasting.
8.5

WINERY:

Off the beaten path situated amidst the Cabernet Sauvignon vines of the valley somewhere between Hwy 29 and the Silverado Trail sits this hidden beauty.
CHATEAU MONTELENA 1429 Tubbs lane, Calistoga 707.942.5105 HOURS: Tasting: 10:00-4:00 Tours: by appointment.

 

Do not arrive too close to the end of tasting time or you may not be well received.


Click for larger image

11

WINE: A winner of the Paris tasting in 1976, Chateau Montalena took the world by storm with its 1973 Chardonnay. While the selection varies, usually 3 wines are poured. The cabernets are generally of an older vintage while the rest are current. All are exceptional.

8

AMBIANCE:

Here you will find a serious wine taster's winery with a serious staff. Go early.

11

WINERY:

After tasting the wines, be sure to walk the grounds where you will see a building reminiscent of a French castle. Follow the garden to the pond. It is truly spectacular.
CHIMNEY ROCK 5350 Silverado Trail, Yountville 707.257.2641 HOURS: Tasting: 10:00-5:00 Tasting Fee: $3.00 Tours: by appointment fee: $5.00.

7

WINE: Situated in the Stag's Leap District, well known for its cabernet sauvignons, appears to have influenced this winery's recent focus on cabs rather than it's longstanding mainstay of a variety of whites.

9

AMBIANCE:

A pleasant high ceiling tasting room greets you warmly as does the staff.

9.5

WINERY:

Stucco stonewalls flank the entrance to the vineyard. The long driveway leads you through the vineyards to the tasting room set at the foot of the mountain. Truly a gem.
CLOS PEGASE 1060 Dunaweal Lane, Calistoga 707.259.2200 HOURS: Tasting: 10:00-5:00 Tours: 11:00 & 2:00/art collection.


Click for larger image

12

WINE: BUY A CASE! Outstanding! Forget the past. Clos Pegase has arrived. The reds: fruity, smooth, delicate, and elegant with a firm hint of tannins at the end. Drink now or cellar and enjoy later!

11

AMBIANCE:

The staff is extremely knowledgeable about the wines and is not shy to recommend their own personal favorites. You will feel at home in this vineyard's tasting room.

12

WINERY:

The grand yet austere facade hides the opulent art collection decorating the winery. The open air gardens in the center are inviting and lead you to the magnificently appointed tasting room where the large casks of wine can be viewed through a sheer glass wall. Taste the wine and experience Clos Pegase culture. Do visit the underground caves.
COSENTINO 7415 St. Helena Highway (Hwy 29), Yountville 707.944.1220 HOURS: Tasting: 10:00-5:30 daily Summer till 5:00 Tours: none Tasting Fee: $3.00

7

WINE: The red is a Bordeaux blend that is fruity and has a tannic finish. The Cigar Zinfandel has become one of Napa's more popular wines with its ripe fruit and spicy finish.

9

AMBIANCE:

A long tasting bar and friendly staff make for a pleasant visit.

8

WINERY:

A modern winery with modest grounds right off of Highway 29 and next door to the famous Mustards Grill.
CUVAISON 4550 Silverado Trail, Calistoga 707.942.6266 HOURS: Tasting: 10:00-5:00 Tours: by appointment.


Click for larger image

9.5

WINE: From Cuvaison's Chardonnay to it's fabulous cabernet and magnificent merlot your palette will welcome the splendor of each. The Eris Vineyard Pinot Noir is outstanding.  These wines are stunning. The Carneros vineyard grapes should not be missed.

11

AMBIANCE:

If your grandparents owned a vineyard, this would be it. Warmth and hospitality permeate the tasting room. Although sometimes busy, an attentive staff makes you feel at home.

10

WINERY:

A split front door welcomes you while the grounds feel like you are on vacation at your very own B & B.
DOMAIN CARNEROS Duhig Road off Highway 12/121(5 miles West of Napa) 707.257.0101 HOURS: Tasting: Mon-Thurs 10:30-6:00, Fri-Sun 11:00-3:00 Tours: 11:00,1:00 & 3:00 daily Tasting Fee: By the glass (Finger foods)


Click for larger image

10.5

WINE: Bubblie, Bubblie, Bubblie! Aside from their recent release of an excellent Pinot Noir this house is dedicated to producing sparkling wines. All of the wines are fresh and delicious especially Domaine Carneros' La Reve. Indulge. A variety, you may order a bottle, sit, sip, relax and enjoy.

11.5

AMBIANCE:

A spectacular "cafe" like atmosphere awaits you at this tasting room with a wait staff that attends to your every tasting need including delicious edibles.

11

WINERY:

Styled after a French chateau perched a top a hill overlooking its' vineyards this winery is a delight for the senses. The tasting room is simple yet, elegantly appointed with high ceilings, a fireplace and beautiful views.
DOMAIN CHANDON California Drive (off Hwy 29), Yountville 707.944.2280 HOURS: Tasting: 11:00 - 6:00 daily hours vary in the winter. Tours: 11:00 - 5:00 on the hour daily. Tasting Fee: Sold by the glass, so prices vary.

 

A Fabulous place for lunch, dinner or just a bottle of bubbly on the patio. The wine list is outstanding & extensive.


Click for larger image

11

WINE: Domain Chandon offers a wide array of sparkling wines, Chandon brings pleasure to all of your senses. From the Roses to the Bruts Chandon is heaven for sparkling wines lovers. The Etoile is Chandon's pricey classic and is well worth every sip.

11

AMBIANCE:

Charm and elegance is the order of the day at Domain Chadon. Sit at a patio table on a sunny day and order by the bottle or glass. Taste fine sparkling wines over a gourmet lunch or please your palette at the tasting bar. The staff is as sophisticated as the wines and will treat you like royalty.

12

WINERY:

Nestled into the countryside this contemporary structure is surrounded by gardens and vineyards. You'll feel as if you have arrived at a very fine country French restaurant.

FORMAN VINEYARDS St. Helena 707.963.0234

 

As Forman is not open to the public, please visit Forman on our Wineries of Special Interest page for more information.

forman.jpg (48732 bytes)
Click for larger image

FRANCISCAN 1178 Galleron road @ Hwy 29, Rutherford 707.963.7111 HOURS: Tasting: 10:00-5:00 Tasting Fee: $3.00 Tours: none

franciscan.jpg (42646 bytes)
Click for larger image

8

WINE: Represented by four labels: Franciscan, Mt. Vedeer, Pinnacles and Estancia. A solid showing across the board. The Mt. Veeder label stands a bottle above the others.

8

AMBIANCE:

Friendly and informative.

7.5

WINERY:

The tasting room and gift shop are one. One might wish for more gardens and typical vineyard scenery.
FREEMARK ABBEY 3022 St. Helena Way (Hwy 29), St. Helena 707.963.9694 HOURS: Tasting: 10:00-5:00 Tasting Fee: $3.00 Tours: 2:00 daily

9

WINE: It's premiere is the sweet dessert wine Edelwein Gold, a Johannesburg Riesling. But don't overlook their cabernet, as it is once again a shinning star of the vineyard.

9

AMBIANCE:

A brief wine education can be found here by the friendly staff.

7.5

WINERY:

A turn of the century stone structure invites you into the comfortable tasting room.
FROG'S LEAP 8815 Conn Creek Road, Rutherford 707.963.4704 HOURS: Tasting & Tours: given Monday-Friday 9:00-4:00 by appointment only.


Click for larger image

9.5

WINE: Frog's zinfandels are stellar and their sauvignon blanc is their shining star. All of Frog's Leap's Wines are delicious. This vineyard is a must for any wine lover.

12

AMBIANCE:

By appointment only unless you happen upon a fair-haired maiden who will invite you in for wine and the fruit that grows in the vineyard. Don't chance it-make a date with Alice in the wonderland of the gardens and vineyards known as Frog's Leap.

11

WINERY:

Nestled into the countryside this contemporary structure is surrounded by gardens and vineyards. You'll feel as if you have stumbled into a country home.
GRGICH HILLS CELLARS 1829 St. Helena Way, Rutherford 707.963.2784  HOURS: Tasting: 9:30-4:30 Tasting Fee: $3.00 (includes etched glass) Tours: by appointment

10.5

WINE: Although very well known for their outstanding chardonnay, their cabs age extremely well. Tannins don't overwhelm even the young cabs, which are consistently extraordinary. Mike Grgich is also well known for producing Chateau Montelena's 1973 Chardonnay, which won the Paris tasting in 1976.

10

AMBIANCE:

Delightful. Modest yet charming. The staff greets you and spends time discussing each wine during the tasting.

9

WINERY:

While the exterior is simple, immediately stepping inside you are enveloped with the aromas of wine and the oak casks, which hold the delightful nectar. The casking room is adjacent to and visible from the tasting room.  Take the tour.
GROTH 750 Oakville Cross Road, Oakville 707.944.0290  HOURS: Tasting: Monday-Saturday 10:00-4:00 Tasting Fee: $5:00 which will be deducted from purchase) Tours: 11:00 & 2:00 Sunday Friday all by appointment. Call or you will be disappointed.


Click for larger image

10

WINE: Less is most certainly more. The focus here is on a handful of premiere Wines; fume blanc, chardonnay and cabernet sauvignon. Don't miss a one. The cabernet is fruitful yet subtle to the palette absorbing gently and elegantly. Buy what you can. Often the premier cabernet is limited to one bottle per visit.

11

AMBIANCE:

A friendly sophisticated staff sits back and allows you to educate and enjoy yourself while sipping on Groth's finest. Don't be afraid to ask questions or engage in conversation because the staff is as fine as the wine. Maybe they will even invite you for lunch.

11

WINERY:

The GROTH WINERY stands regally, set back from the road. The interior is understated and elegant. Take your wine out to the patio overlooking the lush romantic garden. A fine affair in all respects.
HEITZ 436 St.Helena Hwy (Hwy 29), St. Helena 707.963.3542 HOURS: Tasting: 11:00-4:30 Tours: are given at 500 Taplin road Monday Friday 2:00


Click for larger image

10

WINE: A wine to be cellared. Lay Heitz' reds down in your cellar and allow the tannins to work. As the wines in the tasting room are often young and vibrant, age brings about a smooth velvety mature wine to be savored.

8

AMBIANCE:

Plain and gracious. Often only two wines are poured. It's quality not quantity.

7.5

WINERY:

A simple structure with a small pouring room is the home to a very big wine. If you are serious about wines not extravagance, visit this winery.
THE HESS COLLECTION 4411 Redwood Road (approximately 8 miles West of Hwy 29), Napa 707.255.1144 HOURS: Tasting: 10:00-4:00 daily Tours: self guided Tasting Fee: $3.00

 

The drive to the Hess Collection is off the beaten path; the art collection is well worth the trip.

8

WINE: The chardonnay and cab are the standouts. The chardonnay has a strong, classis oaky flavor while the cabernet has the intensity and depth of the mountain soil from which it comes. The zin is also delicious.

11

AMBIANCE:

Fine art and fine wine make this truly an extraordinary experience. It's more than wine, it's culture.

11

WINERY:

This old ivy covered structure is the classic style winery. The grounds are beautifully manicured and adorned with magnificent flowers. Inside is a gift and wine shop, a high ceiling and stone tasting room with several floors of art work. Plan to take your time when visitng.
MERRYVALE 1000 Main Street, St. Helena 707.963.7777 HOURS: Tasting: 10:00-5:30 Tasting Fee: $5.00 Tours: none


Click for larger image

9

WINE: Fine wines, particularly their chardonnay and sauvignon blanc. The profile, a red blend, is the vineyard star.  A tremendous, elegant wine. Merryvale's Antigua, a vermouth, will not disappoint.

11

AMBIANCE:

Great! It's an open warm invitation to sip great wine. You will want to stay for dinner and dine in the fabulously elegant dining room which is only reserved for intimate affairs.

9

WINERY:

The warmth of the interior melts away the stoic exterior. Go inside, sip the wine and enjoy.

 

If not offered for tasting, you may want to splurge and buy a bottle of the profile series red.  It's outstanding!
ROBERT MONDAVI WINERY 7801 St. Helena Highway (Hwy 29), Oakville 800-MONDAVI HOURS: Tastings: 10:00 - 5:00 Tours: On the hour, reservations are highly recommended. Tasting Fee: None with the tour except the reserve wines. Tour fee: $10.00 per person.

 

A fabulous tour not to be missed! Visit the Art Gallery and gift shop before you leave


Click for larger image

10

WINE: The Pinot Noir was absolutely delicious and elegant. The 1996 Zinfandel was a delightful surprise with lots of blackberry and spice, a very jammy and full-bodied wine. The 1996 Reserve Cabernet is styled along the line of traditional cab; Full bodied, deep and rich with complex berry flavors with firm but not overwhelming tannins and long lustrous finish, a truly fine wine.

10

AMBIANCE:

An exceptional staff greets you at the Robert Mondavi Winery. Your tour guide will delight in answering all of your questions as you stroll through the winery and learn of it's history and of Robert Mondavi's life long quest to preserve the environment.

11

WINERY:

Lush manicured lawns and gardens await you at this Spanish Mission like winery.
MUMM NAPA VALLEY 8845 Silverado Trail, Rutherford 707.942.3434  HOURS: Tasting: 10:00-5:00 Tasting Fee: by the flute or 1/2 flute Tours: 11:00-3:00 on the hour

10

WINE: This is a sparkling winery, no pun intended. If you like sparking wine or her French sister, champagne, Mumm is a must. The tasting is plentiful. Blanc de blanc, blanc de Noir and brut are all excellent. You won't go home empty-handed, nor should you.

11

AMBIANCE:

Wait to be seated by the charming staff in a tasting room that looks more like a cafe.  Indoors or outdoors, whatever is your pleasure. You will sip and relax overlooking the splendor of the mumm vineyard.

10

WINERY:

The French owned winery offers the best of both worlds.  If heaven were a sparkling wine vineyard then you will have arrived.
NAPA WINE COMPANY 1133 Oakville Cross Road, Oakville 707.944.1710  HOURS: Tasting: 10:30-3:30 Tasting Fee: $3.00 by appointment Tours: none

N/A

WINE: The wide variety of labels poured here make it an unfair proposition to rate.  There many fine wines, including the excellent Pahlmeyer. Be sure to taste the bold and spicy Fife Zinfandel, a winner. This is a must as the wine offerings are unparrralled.

10

AMBIANCE:

This facility is located just off of Hwy 29 along side railroad tracks that are no longer in use. The tasting room is light and airy. The pourer's come with a sense of humor, which makes their wine expertise less intimidating. Come here to discover the variety of reserve and dessert wines as well.

N/A

WINERY:

As this is a storing and crushing facility for many wines it does not fit into the winery category.
NEWTON VINEYARD 2555 Madrona Avenue, St. Helena 707.963.9000 Tasting & Tours: by appointment only and only on Fridays at 11:00. Tasting fee: none

 

As we did not attend the public tour please visit Newton on our Wineries of Special Interest page for more information


Click for larger image